A restaurant chef preparing a dish

About Us

Where dedication to scratch-made comfort food meets high-energy Butler flavor

Freshly baked Margherita pizza served on a wooden peel

Real Comfort Food Built from Scratch

Cheesy Does It was founded on a simple, delicious promise: to bring authentic, heavy-hitting comfort food to the heart of Butler, Indiana. We believe that great flavor takes time, which is why our kitchen completely bypasses shortcuts. Every morning, we are hard at work prepping our secret-recipe marinara, blending our zesty Buffalo sauce, and simmering the fiery Blazer Hot Sauce that our guests crave.

Freshly baked Margherita pizza served on a wooden peel

The Legendary Four-Blend Mozzarella

You cannot talk about our specialty pizzas or our famous house-made breadsticks without talking about the cheese. Our signature four-blend mozzarella is meticulously selected and combined to achieve the absolute perfect melt, golden color, and epic stretch. It is the crowning glory of every heavily loaded pizza that leaves our oven, delivering that undeniable, soul-satisfying comfort food experience every single time.

Freshly baked Margherita pizza served on a wooden peel

Big Wheels, Live Music, and Local Flavor

We love being a part of the vibrant energy that makes Butler so special. Located just down the road from the International Monster Truck Museum and Hall of Fame, we have become the go-to refueling spot for families, travelers, and motor-heads alike. Whether you are coming in to discuss your favorite full-sized legendary trucks or joining us for the incredible local talent during our live music nights on select Fridays, Cheesy Does It is all about celebration, community, and unforgettable local excitement.